Skip to main content

Table 3B Shows the ranking of the energy devices for each of the outcomes with the P score in parentheses where a P-value of 1.00 is the highest and P-value of 0.00 is the lowest. The bolded value for Argon cautery indicate that is the best technique for reducing blood loss

From: The effectiveness of different flap-raising techniques for mastectomy in reducing the rate of complications: a network meta-analysis

 

Seroma

Volume of drain

Blood loss

Flap necrosis

Rank 1

Sharp dissection (P = 83.9)

Harmonic scalpel (P = 86.3)

Argon cautery (P = 90.9)

Harmonic scalpel (P = 84.4)

Rank 2

Harmonic scalpel (P = 79.3)

Argon cautery (P = 62.1)

Harmonic scalpel (P = 55.1)

Sharp dissection (P = 61.8)

Rank 3

Argon cautery (P = 55.4)

Diathermy (P = 48.8)

Plasma blade (P = 38.7)

Diathermy (P = 3.7)

Rank 4

LigaSure (P = 40.4)

Plasma blade (P = 43.5)

LigaSure (P = 33.1)

-

Rank 5

Diathermy (P = 30.3)

Sharp dissection (P = 34.7)

Diathermy (P = 31.9)

-

Rank 6

Plasma blade (P = 10.6)

LigaSure (P = 24.5)

-

-